In order of my favorite performances:
Casey - Unbelievable! Great stage presence and not a note off key.
James - Perfect! Not screechy and sounded beautiful.
Thia - Like the judges, I didn't care for the middle part at all, but I think she has a beautiful voice. I see her doing a lot of animated Disney princess voice overs.
Naima - I think this would have been incredible if she hadn't been so nervous. I really like her.
Jacob - He seemed so nervous in the beginning, I thought he was going to have a meltdown. The rest of the song was beautiful though. His pants were too tight.
Stefano - Sounded great, but I found his performance to be manic. Made me nervous.
Pia - Excellent vocal, but she bores me. I find her big notes to be a little flat, but who am I to say?
Lauren - Great voice, but I thought her performance was a mess. I like her though.
Scotty - Very good vocal, but also boring for me. He has a future in the recording business no matter what happens on Idol.
Haley - I like this girl, but did not like her performance at all.
Ashthon - Doesn't do a thing for me. She looked really beautiful though.
Paul - Love him, but what the hell? I thought he was awful and I HATE to say that.
Karen - Bad, bad, bad. Unless she gets a huge block of hispanic votes, she's going home.